Georgia’s Toothless Preemption Law Invites Gun-Rights Violations © 2026 Red Clay Watch

Newton County Gun-Rights Lawsuit: Twelve Years After HB 60, It’s Time for Real Teeth

A father should not need a lawyer to attend his children’s ballgames at a public park without surrendering a right the law protects.

AI-generated editorial illustration for Red Clay Watch. The people and scene are fictional, not a depiction of the actual encounter.

Georgia’s Safe Carry Protection Act, HB 60, took effect July 1, 2014. That was twelve years ago.

Local governments have had ample time to review their policies, remove unlawful restrictions, and train their employees. The question now is whether Georgia lawmakers will make compliance a responsibility with consequences, rather than a burden dumped on whichever citizen finally decides to sue.

What McCray alleges

According to Sam Sachs’s September 14 WSB-TV report, Javance McCray sued Newton County and Deputy Tyrone Major on September 8 over encounters at City Pond Park during his children’s sporting events.

McCray alleges that, despite holding a weapons carry license (no longer required for lawful carriers after Jan. 2022), Major repeatedly ordered him to put his holstered handgun in his vehicle during April and May.

Attorney John R. Monroe is handling the suit.

WSB quotes McCray’s reason for complying:

“out of fear of arrest and prosecution if he refused.”

Major later allegedly cited a judge’s advice and required concealment instead. WSB also quotes McCray’s claim that he:

“was embarrassed and humiliated ... as he is known to many in the community.”

The suit challenges weapons-prohibition signs at multiple parks and seeks their removal, an end to enforcement, damages, and attorney’s fees. His children reportedly feared his arrest.

These are allegations, not findings. WSB sought county comment; its report includes no substantive response.

The courts addressed this before HB 60

The basic legal problem with a county-created park gun ban is not new.

On December 4, 2007, the Georgia Court of Appeals decided GeorgiaCarry.Org, Inc. v. Coweta County. Coweta County’s ordinance prohibited firearms at county recreation facilities, sports fields, and surrounding county property.

The court held that state law expressly preempted the ordinance and reversed the ruling in the county’s favor. Addressing the statutory language, it wrote:

“Here, however, the language of the statute is not doubtful.”

John R. Monroe represented the challengers in that case, too.

That decision is almost nineteen years old. HB 60 later added a civil enforcement remedy to the preemption statute.

How many legislative sessions, legal opinions, and training opportunities should it take before citizens can count on officials to follow established state law?

A badge is not a legislative pen

O.C.G.A. § 16-11-173 generally reserves regulation of firearms and other weapons to the state. Its prohibition on unauthorized local regulation reaches possession and carrying, and it expressly includes regulation imposed “by any other means.”

That language matters. The preemption problem does not disappear merely because a restriction is delivered verbally instead of printed in an ordinance.

A locally invented concealment requirement would still regulate carrying. Calling it a compromise would not supply the missing legal authority.

Public city, county, and state parks are not prohibited locations under Georgia’s unauthorized-locations statute.

The proper question is what the law authorizes, not what an official would prefer.

Sheriff Brown and the county should answer

Sheriff Ezell Brown should explain what his deputies are taught about lawful carry and state preemption.

Was Major following written policy, instructions from a supervisor, or his own interpretation? Who reviewed any claimed restriction for compliance with state law?

County officials should identify who authorized the challenged signs and what legal authority they believe supports them.

Those are questions, not conclusions about who knew what. They deserve answers supported by records, not a round of officials pointing at one another.

Even when an encounter begins with an employee’s misunderstanding, the institution must answer for its training, supervision, and response. The next visitor should not face the same problem.

Training is a management responsibility. Correcting unlawful policy should not be a citizen-funded project.

A lawsuit afterward is not enough

Georgia’s law already provides remedies. Under § 16-11-173(g), an aggrieved person may bring an action, seek equitable relief such as an injunction, and recover actual damages or $100, whichever is greater. The provision also entitles an aggrieved person to reasonable attorney’s fees and litigation expenses. Liability and the proper relief remain for the court to determine.

The $100 is a floor, not a cap. Pretending the statute has no remedies would be inaccurate.

But a remedy after the fact does not prevent an unlawful restriction from accomplishing its purpose in the moment.

An officer can give an instruction in seconds. A citizen challenging it must find counsel, gather evidence, and pursue relief. Meanwhile, the immediate choice may be to surrender the right, leave, or risk escalation.

That is not an acceptable model for routine compliance with state law.

And when a government pays damages from public funds, taxpayers bear that cost. Public-entity liability matters, but it is not a substitute for personal accountability when a decision-maker knowingly maintains an unlawful restriction.

Kemp’s veto points toward a fix

In 2026, Governor Brian Kemp vetoed Senate Bill 204, which would have strengthened firearms-preemption remedies. His official veto message objected to exposing officers to personal-capacity lawsuits when they had no role in enacting the challenged ordinance.

But Kemp also wrote:

“I wholeheartedly support increasing the monetary penalties for local governments that attempt to impede the rights of lawful weapon carriers”

He said penalties should target the leaders responsible for enacting the ordinances rather than officers tasked with enforcing them.

Lawmakers should take that stated support seriously and return with a better-targeted bill in 2027.

Protecting employees from a new personal penalty for decisions they had no authority to make does not require shielding officials who knowingly make, maintain, or direct unlawful policy.

Nor should reform erase existing remedies for an officer’s own unlawful conduct. The answer is careful drafting, not blanket immunity and another year of excuses.

What real teeth should look like

Make the responsible public entity answer financially. Substantially increase the $100 minimum and authorize enhanced damages for knowing or repeated violations. Preserve attorney’s fees, litigation expenses, and prompt injunctive relief. Clearly identify covered defendants and address immunity so enforceable rights are not undermined by avoidable drafting disputes.

Target knowing decision-makers personally. Create a separate civil penalty for officials with final authority who knowingly adopt, continue, or direct unlawful weapons restrictions. Require proof and due process. Do not let officials simply transfer a personal penalty to the taxpayers.

Written notice should make continued noncompliance more consequential, not become a free pass for the first violation.

Require prevention, not just litigation. Mandate regular review of ordinances, signs, websites, facility rules, and enforcement instructions. Require documented training and timely written responses to complaints identifying an unlawful restriction.

A policy quietly changed after a lawsuit is filed should not automatically erase an otherwise valid claim for damages or fees.

These proposals are not demands for special treatment. They are demands that public officials follow the law and that the people with authority to stop a violation have a real incentive to do so.

The General Assembly should strengthen compliance, not create new local gun-ban exceptions that reward resistance to existing law.


Contact your lawmakers now

Contact both your Georgia state representative and state senator. The state’s legislator-contact guide links to the official tools for finding them.

Send them the WSB report and this article. Ask them to sponsor and support a 2027 preemption-enforcement bill with meaningful public-entity damages, targeted personal penalties, and mandatory policy review and training.

A message can be this direct:

“Please strengthen O.C.G.A. § 16-11-173 in 2027. Preserve meaningful remedies against responsible public entities and add personal penalties for officials who knowingly maintain unlawful weapons restrictions. Require policy review and training. Twelve years after HB 60, citizens should not have to risk arrest or finance litigation to obtain compliance with established state law. What specific action will you take?”

Ask for a commitment to legislation, not another form letter praising the Second Amendment.

Public officials expect citizens to know and obey the law. They should be held to that standard themselves.

Georgia should not need a plaintiff at every park.

Comments